More evidence confirms the error of stopping land value tax in Pittsburgh
Center for the Study of Economics - Company Message
RSS Follow Become a Fan

Delivered by FeedBurner

Recent Posts

LVT in Los Angeles? Op-Ed says go for it.
Welcome to the Zany World of NYC's Property Tax
Land Value Taxation in Jamaica: Now More Than Ever
Part 1, Land Value Taxation: Politics, Persuasion, and Practicality - A How-To
2016: Another Year of Advances and Retrenchment

Most Popular Posts

Noted UK Think Tank: Tax Land Values
Eliminating the property tax? It must not happen, but we’ll see what happens.
Altoona, PA: City tax wholly on land values = normality
Land Value Tax in Britain: Progress While the Rear Guard Digs In
Dr. Herbert Barry's Proposal to Really Reassess Allegheny County


Act 47
Affordable Housing
Agricultural Policy
Allegheny County
Australian Capital Territory
Connecticut General Assembly
Current News Item
de Blasio
Economic Development
Economic Policy
Economic Rent
Ed Vargas
Federal Tax Policy
Fiscal Policy and Taxes
Free Markets
George Osborne
Global Taxation
Healthy Communities
Housing Policy
Hurricane Sandy
Jeffrey Berger
Jimmy Tayoun
Justin Skariah
Kenyatta Johnson
Land Policy
Land Value Tax
Larry Deutsch
Law and the Constitution
Len Fasano
Liberal Democrats
Local Government
Los Angeles
Maria Quinones-Sanchez
Martin Looney
Matt Ritter
Matthew Ritter
Mayor Rick Gray
Michael Kinsley
Model Legislation
Monroe County
National Tax Policy
New Jersey
New London
New York City
Parking and Transportation
Patricia Dillon
Property Assessment
Property Tax Reform
Public Health
Public Opinion
Public Resources
Public Works
Regional Tax Base Sharing
Rhode Island
Roland Lemar
Sales Taxes
Senator Jan Malik
Sin Taxes
Smart Growth
Soda Tax
Tax Exemption and Abatment
Thomas Piketty
Tom Kramer
Transportation Funding
Transportation Policy
United Kingdom
Urban Blight
Urban Rejuvenation
Urban Tax Policy
Vince Cable
Wage and Income Taxes
Wilson Goode Jr.
powered by

Incentive Taxation

More evidence confirms the error of stopping land value tax in Pittsburgh

Q. What happens when a city taxes buildings more at the beginning of the greatest building boom in American history?
A. Not much.

One of the best examples of the efficacy of land value tax (LVT) was careful study of the city of Pittsburgh culminating in the Oates/Schwab study of Pittsburgh published in 1997 which concluded all things being equal land value tax policy had the effect of unleashing construction demand – especially downtown construction –just as the steel industry collapsed, and just as the US entered a significant recessionary period (late 1970s and early 1980s)

After a botched revaluation by Allegheny County in Pittsburgh in the year 2000, the sprawl/development community/suburban power centers based outside the cities created enough havoc with the data, all in the midst of a savage mayoral primary. Then-city leaders made a reactive choice and "suspended" LVT.

What were the results?  Certainly, as the nation entered a period of tremendous growth especially in the construction industry, Pittsburgh's taxable building permits dropped.  What development there was, came as the result of heavy lifting by the taxpayers as the "development community" were showered with abatements, subsidies and TIFs, which continues unabated to this day (Pun intended).

New construction is generally limited to condos and other high ticket items.  Older neighborhoods such as the Hill District,  the North Side, Carrick and Beltzhoover, the meat and bones(if you will) of Pittsburgh were slammed with significantly higher tax levies. More and more land has gone off the tax rolls.

A TIF-driven dream: A Developer pays himself to build at 350 5th

Another Wrinkle

All bad news no doubt.  But another issue that has been a constant is the fact that just when LVT was ended, property tax revenues stagnated (again during a huge boom in construction throughout the nation).  Property tax revenues are still far short of what the city expects and needs.

While a healthy property tax base can pay for most if not all of the city's revenues, Pittsburgh wants permission to scrounge in the sofa for loose change, and is wishing for the very type of taxes that are regressive and damaging long-term to an economy: local wage and consumption taxes. In fact, LVT was the replacement for a wage tax, twice enacted by the late and very lamented Mayor Sophie Masloff. 

Despite all the infectious happy talk about Pittsburgh's rebirth, demographic and economic indicators all point downwards.

Perhaps it's time Pittsburgh returns to the future and double down by stripping away inefficient taxes and grants of unfair privilege to the well-connected in exchange for sweat equity and real construction projects.  Return the city to the land value tax, and include the school district tax as well.  Announce that the new protected class in Pittsburgh will be those who want to work, build, and produce a better community.

9 Comments to More evidence confirms the error of stopping land value tax in Pittsburgh:

Comments RSS
top celebrity jackets on Saturday, May 12, 2018 4:16 AM
Do you guys work for waste management or a related business? I would love to learn more about industrial waste management for my college assignment.
Reply to comment

essay writing service australia on Saturday, May 26, 2018 12:31 PM
Land tax is now very important for those who have big property. We know that its very difficult to have and stable this kind of property in these days. But if you have wast family then this was best for you.
Reply to comment

ukbestessays on Wednesday, June 06, 2018 4:25 PM
Well, why should I care about this error? Can you tell me why it's important?
Reply to comment

Venom Jacket on Tuesday, July 31, 2018 8:51 AM
We all want to pay taxes because it will help our government to build up the education process and help those poor people who want to go to school and want to become a good person and support there, family
Reply to comment

Deadpool Jacket on Friday, August 03, 2018 1:39 AM
It is most famously associated with Henry George book Progress and Poverty which argued that because the supply of land is fixed. its location value is created by communities and public works
Reply to comment

Click Here on Monday, August 13, 2018 3:58 AM
Thanks for this wonderful article it was nice and amazing.
Reply to comment

William on Wednesday, October 03, 2018 6:41 AM
every people payed taxes with on time and government should better education. Informative post thanks for sharing us.
Reply to comment

Harley Davidson Marlboro Man Jacket on Sunday, November 18, 2018 5:50 AM
You should must learning about land value tax on wiki.
Reply to comment

Katherine McNamara Green Jacket on Tuesday, December 04, 2018 8:06 AM
Financial aspects are the investigation of how social orders utilize rare assets to deliver important wares and convey them among various individuals. Behind this definition are two key thoughts in financial matters: that products are rare and that society must utilize its assets effectively.
Reply to comment

Add a Comment

Your Name:
Email Address: (Required)
Make your text bigger, bold, italic and more with HTML tags. We'll show you how.
Post Comment